Pinhook “Rye Munny” ($38)

Pinhook “Rye Munny” ($38)

Rye doesn’t get prettier than this! Many Rye whiskies rely totally on spice tones to get their point across. It’s a horse of a different color here, with notes of clover and honey starting things off and moving gently toward more spice throughout the proceedings....
Castle & Key Restoration Rye ($47)

Castle & Key Restoration Rye ($47)

The spicy rye notes on this are quite evident. Up front the rye takes center stage, as it should, and what follows is supporting caramel, butterscotch, sugared almond, resin and light citrus notes. Castle & Key offers a very pleasant rye whiskey at a price that...
Old Forester Kentucky Straight Rye Whisky ($35)

Old Forester Kentucky Straight Rye Whisky ($35)

This packs a rye punch early on. From the first sip the very spicy notes are evident, almost overwhelmingly so. As the rye calms down the toffee, resin and caramel flavors begin to emerge, along with citrus zest and a muted honey.  There are also light notes of clove,...
Keeper’s Heart Irish + Bourbon, Cask Strength ($50)

Keeper’s Heart Irish + Bourbon, Cask Strength ($50)

Tread carefully here – the seductive nose of this interesting combination of ideas will lull you into thinking you’ve got a mellow sipper on your hands, so heed the “cask strength” moniker.  I’m almost completely content with nosing this beauty – pure grain...
Ammunition Straight Rye Whiskey  ($42)

Ammunition Straight Rye Whiskey ($42)

Typically, I’m not a fan of finished bourbons or ryes in various flavor-of-the-month barrels, in part because they seem to be in a type of wood not conducive to helping the spirit attain maturity in any meaningful way. I have to say, however, that the Ammunition Rye,...
Tap 357 Maple Rye Whisky ($36)

Tap 357 Maple Rye Whisky ($36)

There’s an initial sweetness to this – no surprise since maple is in the name. Tap 357 was finished with Canadian maple syrup sourced from Quebec. This begins with a blend of 3, 5, and 7-year Canadian rye whiskies that have aged in used bourbon barrels. The...